NewJeans Hyein Faces Controversy Over Skipping Some Birthday Cafés on 21st
NewJeans member Hyein was recently at the center of a fans’ debate after visiting several birthday cafés organized by fans to celebrate her birthday, but not all of them. While Hyein made appearances at some of these cafés, her absence at others led to disappointment among the fans who had hosted the unvisited events.
NewJeans Hyein Fans sad that she skipped some birthday cafes
“Even if I try to think positively, if she was only going to visit a few, she shouldn’t have started at all. It’s not like she set out to mess with people’s heads, but this is just too much.” “I’m just so dumbfounded, I can only cry. Honestly, I don’t even feel that sorry—I just can’t end this with good memories.” The fans wrote their feelings at X (formerly called Twitter).
While some fans expressed disappointment that Hyein wasn’t able to visit every birthday café, her public handwritten letter was simply meant to convey her apologies for not being able to attend all the events, rather than directly addressing or acknowledging any controversy. There is no clear evidence that Hyein was fully aware of being at the center of a major dispute; her message reflected a general sense of gratitude and regret to fans she couldn’t meet in person.
I actually wanted to visit the places I couldn’t go to today, but just as I arrived in front of them, my stomach started hurting so much that I couldn’t go in. That’s why I wanted to say I’m sorry for not being able to visit everyone equally
Hyein’s handwritten letter
The situation quickly sparked further discussion within the fandom. Some fans criticized those expressing disappointment, arguing that it was unfair to pressure Hyein over which cafés she could visit and emphasizing the burden such expectations place on idols. As the conversation continues, the incident has highlighted the delicate balance between idol-fan interactions and the intense scrutiny celebrities face over even small personal choices.
[Knetz Reaction] NewJeans Hyein Birthday Cafe Issue
@forevernj722
I kind of understand how someone could feel really down if they prepared for a long time and Hyein didn’t come to theirs. But it wasn’t mandatory, and she still risked her safety and showed her face—honestly, it seems like Hyein went out of her way to at least thank the people who organized the cafés. I doubt she intentionally skipped just one or two; maybe something happened? I hope she spent her birthday well with her family.
@amorrmanet
I’m so upset I can’t sleep. I don’t have a private or side account, so I’m just muttering to myself and it’s so frustrating. Just thinking about seeing those nasty comments makes my heart ache. This isn’t a direct attack, but if you feel guilty, I’m not sorry. If you think you’re going to have a mental breakdown, please just go see a psychiatrist.
@amorrmanet
Please don’t tell her what to do. And don’t blast your opinions in public spaces where everyone can see. If you have something to say, please practice writing it in your own diary instead. Seriously…
What do you think about NewJeans Hyein Birthday cafe absence controversy?
Previous article about Knetz Reactions > [Knetz Reaction] Is TWICE Jeongyeon trying to ride on DAY6’s popularity?
